Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Adrião Pereira da Cunha's avatar

There’s something quietly magical about this poem, the way Celan turns stones things we expect to be hard and heavy into something soft, bright, almost tender. The image of them opening like dog roses feels so unexpected and yet so right, like a moment of beauty appearing where you least expect it. I love how the stones don’t fall or strike; instead, they drift toward someone loved, someone quiet and true. There’s a gentleness in that movement that stays with you. And the idea of gathering these bright stones with “everyman’s hands” makes the whole scene feel humble and human, as if anyone could hold something sacred. The ending carries this soft sense of release, placing the brightness somewhere beyond grief or naming. It’s a small poem, but it leaves a glow behind, the kind that lingers long after you finish reading.

Tara Mesalik MacMahon's avatar

what a beautiful, beautiful poem, melancholy but fills me, sad/happy/sad. This translation is also so beautiful. I looked up Paul Celan to learn more about him ,and I feel mostly speechless after reading. https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poets/paul-celan. What a life, what courage--a holocaust survivor, but not really. So grateful for this poem, thank you ONLY POEMS.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?